Fall 2022 Gjoa Haven: Difference between revisions

From Knowledge-land-scape
Saskia (talk | contribs)
Saskia (talk | contribs)
 
(29 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
Luckily, it is much easier to set up such meetings in Gjoa Haven, than it was in Coral Harbour. Due to the much wider relational network here, it was more clear how to engage in collective dialogue and logistically produce a gathering that meets community desires.
Luckily, it is much easier to set up such meetings in Gjoa Haven, than it was in Coral Harbour. Due to the much wider relational network here, it was more clear how to engage in collective dialogue and logistically produce a gathering that meets community desires.
    
    
<div class="next_choice">Keep going to find out what the final workshop agendas in both communities emerged to be, how we evaluated them and what was reported back to funders.  
<div class="next_choice">'''"Keep Going"''' to find out what the final workshop agendas in both communities, how we evaluated them and what was reported back to funders.  


You may also detour to a different cut that guides you along our preparation and workshop activities step-by-step. Taking this detour brings you into Cut 2: Aesthetic Action and provides an opening to engage with the affective dynamics of this final gathering in Gjoa Haven. </div>


<span class="detour to cut 2 link" data-page-title="Workshop Gjoa Haven" data-section-id="1" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Workshop Gjoa Haven#Design Consultation Pre-Workshop & Workshop Gjoa Haven|Cut 2: Gjoa Haven (Pre-)Gathering]]</span>
or,
 
 
'''"Detour"''' to cut 2 along our workshop preparations step-by-step. You will not return here. </div>
 
<span class="detour to-cut-2 link" data-page-title="Point of Beginning (Pre-)workshops" data-section-id="1" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Point of Beginning (Pre-)workshops#Design Consultation Pre-Workshop & Workshop Gjoa Haven|Detour to cut 2: (Pre-)Gatherings]]</span>


=Winter 2022 Final Workshops=
=Winter 2022 Final Workshops=


In Gjoa Haven we organized a three-day gathering, that was preceded by a two-day pre-workshop that fed into the design of the gathering.  
In Gjoa Haven we organized a three-day gathering, that was preceded by a two-day pre-workshop that fed into the design of the gathering.  
The final gathering was kicked-off the evening before with a community feast and the screening of the three movies that were co-created with the community and the HTA. Following these screenings Marsha Branigan, the recently retired government-biologist of the North-western Territories, presented on the the governance structure of polar bears as to set an informative background for the upcoming three days.
 
In Coral Harbour we ended u with a two day final gathering, spread between school activities and the hamlet conference room.


[[File:Agenda GH gathering.png|thumb]]
[[File:Agenda GH gathering.png|thumb]]


The first day consisted of presentations from the BearWatch scientists.  
[[File:Print poster CH.png|thumb]]


The second day was designed to be a collective exercise, providing an opening to encounter each other in renewed ways and gain insights into what knowledge conciliation beyond a data-driven approach could look like.  
<div class="next_choice">'''"Keep Going"''' to find out how we evaluated both workshops and what was reported back to funders.  


The third day consisted of a collective discussion that included a community-panel on "living with polar bears", bringing together community insights, science and management to set a direction for future work.


Although in Coral Harbour we did not manage to organize a pre-workshop, we did combine our two-days workshop with multiple school activities - including a sponsored lunch, a science bingo, and the collective building of a Qamutiq, that was donated to the school after.
or,  


[[File:Print poster CH.png|thumb]]


<div class="next_choice">Keep going to find out how we evaluated both workshops and what was reported back to funders.  
'''"Detour"''' to Cut 2 for a day-to-day journey through each workshop.  


You may also detour to a different cut that guides you along the preparation and workshop activities step-by-step. Taking this detour brings you into Cut 2: Aesthetic Action and provides an opening to engage with the affective dynamics of this final gathering in Coral Harbour. </div>
</div>


<span class="detour link" data-page-title="workshop Coral Harbour" data-section-id="1" data-encounter-type="detour">[[workshop Coral Harbour#Design Consultation Pre-Workshop & Workshop Coral Harbour|Cut 2:Coral Harbour Gathering]]</span>
<span class="detour to-cut-2 link" data-page-title="Preparation Gjoa Haven Workshop" data-section-id="1" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Preparation Gjoa Haven Workshop#3 day Workshop Gjoa Haven|Detour to Cut 2:Final Gatherings]]</span>


=BW Final Reporting=
=Evaluations=


Both workshops were evaluated in different ways.  
Both workshops were evaluated in different ways.  


The three-day workshop in Gjoa Haven had multiple evaluation moments. One evaluative moment took place right after the the building of the Igloo on day-two. everyone who had participated in the activity gather into a warm tent and were served soup. Afterward we each shared our throughts on the activity while eating soup and pilot biscuits with spam. The second collective evaluative moment took place on the morning after the three-day workshop, in the same space we had gathered for the other parts of the workshop. Present at this second evaluation were two elders, the Gjoa Haven HTA vice-chair and our interpretor, as well as the BearWatch funders, PI's, the former government biologist of NWT, and two BearWatch researchers including me. The latter evaluation was lead my me, and the questions were based on key concepts that had emerged from my auto-ethnographic notes, literature and, most importantly, on the terms of engagement that were drafted during the pre-gathering and that were agreed upon across the workshop organizers prior to our gathering.
In Gjoa Haven, we had conducted a pre-workshop to agree upon terms of engagement and held multiple evaluations to understand participant experiences.
 
In Coral Harbour, the funders were not present for the workshop, nor was our local co-PI.  
 
Neither had the conditions been in place for us to organize a pre-workshop with community members during the earlier visit in the community.
 
So, instead we opted to hold a smaller pre-workshop, and post-workshop meeting with the two BearWatch PI's, the former government biologist of NWT and I.


In Coral Harbour, the funders did not join, nor did one of our PI's and the other researcher, that had been present in Gjoa Haven. Our local PI Leonard Netser was unavailable for the final gathering. The conditions had furthermore not been in place for us to organize a pre-workshop with community members during the earlier visit in the community. Instead, we opted to hold a smaller pre-workshop meeting with the two BearWatch PI's, the former government biologist of NWT and I, as well as a meeting with the local interpretor, who we had hired to work with us in Coral Harbour. This pre-workshop was prefaced on "lessons-learnt" from the Gjoa Haven Gathering, without presuming that the terms of engagement drafted in the previous community would apply in Coral Harbour as well. During this pre-workshop meeting, and with the input of the interpretor, we agreed upon certain processes to be applied in the Corl Harbour gathering. Subsequently we evaluated these processes in a post-workshop evaluation with the same group of people.
=Emergent Insights=


In February 2023, the next year, I conducted eight follow-up individual interviews with the Southern researchers, government biologist, funders of the BearWatch project and the interpretor from Gjoa Haven to discuss their experiences of the workshops, two months after it had taken place.
In February 2023, the next year, I conducted eight follow-up individual interviews with the Southern researchers, government biologist, funders of the BearWatch project and the interpretor from Gjoa Haven to discuss their experiences of the workshops, two months after it had taken place.


<div class="next_choice">Not all insights are immediate, or measurable.
Sometimes, possibilities to think with- emerge from in-between the lines, rather than within them - and they may take time to unveil themselves.
My efforts to employ creative methods and aesthetic action, as a way to create new conditions and possibilities to encounter each other during the final gatherings, had seemingly succeeded in some ways, while meeting resistance in others.
While recovering from an intense final season of the BearWatch project, slowly but surely, a figure, with a renewed meaning materializes: The Shipwreck.
Explore how this '''"landmark"''' insight became a defining feature of this knowledge-land-scape.
Or,




<span class="pop-up stay-with-the-trouble link" data-page-title="Politics of In-action and Refusal" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="Stay_with_the_trouble">[[Politics of In-action and Refusal|Stay with the trouble: Politics of In-action and Refusal]]</span>
'''"Keep Going"''' to reach the end of this cut.</div>


<span class="Pop-up landmark link" data-page-title="The Wreck-site" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="Landmark">[[The Wreck-site|Landmark: The Wreck-site]]</span>
<span class="pop-up landmark link" data-page-title="The Wreck-site" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="landmark">[[The Wreck-site|Landmark: The Wreck-site]]</span>


=Another Point of Beginning=
=Another Point of Beginning=


<span class="detour to cut 2 link" data-page-title="Aesthetic_Action" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Aesthetic Action|Detour:Cut 2 Aesthetic Action Point of Beginning]]</span>
You have reached "Another Point of Beginning".
 
This is where we take account for our journey so far.
 
You can trace the path you have taken through this Knowledge-Land-Scape by clicking the "trace" bar in the upper left corner of your screen. It will allow you to account for some of the insights that your journey has given you.
 
The map below shows you the full extent of wayfaring possibilities of the scape.
 
<HTML><iframe width="768" height="432" src="https://miro.com/app/live-embed/uXjVLuaaSIw=/?moveToViewport=-6303,-1839,4422,3256&embedId=190872630107" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" allow="fullscreen; clipboard-read; clipboard-write" allowfullscreen></iframe></html>
 
<div class="next_choice"> Cut 3 has guided you along the journey of the community-based dynamics of the BearWatch project.
 
You have been able to thread your own way alongside me and many of the other agential forces that shaped this project.
 
In the context of community-based research our movements through the world matter. Are we simply transporting ourselves from one point to another, leaving inanimate traces towards predetermined destinations, or are we finding our way along, in lively response to our own unfolding narratives and that of others around us?
 
'''"Keep Going"''' to explore how the different research output creations have continued their material agencies beyond this cut.</div>
 
=Beyond the Cut=
 
[[File:Beyond the cut.png|thumb]]
 
Over the course of 7 years, the BearWatch project has- among others:
 
a) optimized SNP and genetic sex profiling of polar bear feces - allowing non-invasive identification and sexing of individual polar bears, b) optimized meta-barcoding assays that allow the identification of vertebrate prey and plant diet identification from polar bear faeces - allowing non-invasive monitoring of diet switching of genetically tagged individual bears, c) determined the relationship between heavy metal contaminants in a polar bears faeces and it’s muscle, liver and fat profile-  allowing for noninvasive monitoring of spatial and temporal contaminant loads across the Arctic and , d) optimized the species level detection of micro plastic in polar bear faeces - allowing for the real time monitoring of these contaminants in the arctic ecosystem.
 
Such non-invasive methods will be most valuable, however, when employed as part of sustainable collaborative efforts between biologists and Inuit communities.
 
The insights coming from my wayfaring method and prospective aesthetic action within the BearWatch project, have materialized in insights and spaces that may allow for continued work in Gjoa Haven on renewed terms of engagement.
 
Instead of participation and integration of Inuit Knowledge, follow-up research between BearWatch PI's and Gjoa Haven has now been formulated in terms of co-leadership and is preceded by a "setting of the table", which will include the negotiation of knowledge weaving methods and decision-making protocols under guidance of the ICC EEE protocols, and in according with the principles of Ethical Engagement.
 
No follow-up project has, so far, materialized with-in Coral Harbour.
 


<span class="detour to cut 2 link" data-page-title="Aesthetic_Action" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Aesthetic Action#Aesthetic (in)action in BearWatch|Detour:Cut 2 Aesthetic (in)action in BearWatch]]</span>


<span class="detour to cut 2 link" data-page-title="Point of Beginning Mx. Science" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Point of Beginning Mx. Science|Detour:Cut 2 Point of Beginning Mx. Science]]</span>


<span class="detour to cut 1 link" data-page-title="Voices of Thunder" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Voices of Thunder|Detour:Cut 1 Voices of Thunder]]</span>
<span class="detour to-cut-1 link" data-page-title="Voices of Thunder" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Voices of Thunder|Detour to Cut 1: Voices of Thunder]]</span>


<span class="detour to cut 3 link" data-page-title="Wayfaring the BW project Point of Beginning" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Wayfaring the BW project Point of Beginning|Detour:Cut 3 Wayfaring the BW project]]</span>
<span class="detour to-cut-2 link" data-page-title="Aesthetic_Action" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Aesthetic Action|Detour to Cut 2: Aesthetic Action Point of Beginning]]</span>


<span class="detour link" data-page-title="Exploring Polar Bear Research as Ethical Space, Practice and Process of Engagement: Knowledge-land-scape" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Exploring Polar Bear Research as Ethical Space, Practice and Process of Engagement: Knowledge-land-scape|Detour to the title page]]</span>
<span class="detour to-cut-3 link" data-page-title="Wayfaring the BearWatch Project" data-section-id="0" data-encounter-type="detour">[[Wayfaring the BearWatch Project|Detour to Cut 3: Wayfaring the BearWatch Project]]</span>

Latest revision as of 14:20, 4 March 2025

After losing a week in travel delays, there is a lot of preparation left to do for the final workshop in Gjoa Haven- starting with the organization of a "special meeting" with the HTA to finetune the agenda, invitees, and logistical set-up of the meeting.

Luckily, it is much easier to set up such meetings in Gjoa Haven, than it was in Coral Harbour. Due to the much wider relational network here, it was more clear how to engage in collective dialogue and logistically produce a gathering that meets community desires.

"Keep Going" to find out what the final workshop agendas in both communities, how we evaluated them and what was reported back to funders.


or,


"Detour" to cut 2 along our workshop preparations step-by-step. You will not return here.

Detour to cut 2: (Pre-)Gatherings

Winter 2022 Final Workshops[edit]

In Gjoa Haven we organized a three-day gathering, that was preceded by a two-day pre-workshop that fed into the design of the gathering.

In Coral Harbour we ended u with a two day final gathering, spread between school activities and the hamlet conference room.

"Keep Going" to find out how we evaluated both workshops and what was reported back to funders.


or,


"Detour" to Cut 2 for a day-to-day journey through each workshop.

Detour to Cut 2:Final Gatherings

Evaluations[edit]

Both workshops were evaluated in different ways.

In Gjoa Haven, we had conducted a pre-workshop to agree upon terms of engagement and held multiple evaluations to understand participant experiences.

In Coral Harbour, the funders were not present for the workshop, nor was our local co-PI.

Neither had the conditions been in place for us to organize a pre-workshop with community members during the earlier visit in the community.

So, instead we opted to hold a smaller pre-workshop, and post-workshop meeting with the two BearWatch PI's, the former government biologist of NWT and I.

Emergent Insights[edit]

In February 2023, the next year, I conducted eight follow-up individual interviews with the Southern researchers, government biologist, funders of the BearWatch project and the interpretor from Gjoa Haven to discuss their experiences of the workshops, two months after it had taken place.

Not all insights are immediate, or measurable.

Sometimes, possibilities to think with- emerge from in-between the lines, rather than within them - and they may take time to unveil themselves.

My efforts to employ creative methods and aesthetic action, as a way to create new conditions and possibilities to encounter each other during the final gatherings, had seemingly succeeded in some ways, while meeting resistance in others.

While recovering from an intense final season of the BearWatch project, slowly but surely, a figure, with a renewed meaning materializes: The Shipwreck.

Explore how this "landmark" insight became a defining feature of this knowledge-land-scape.


Or,


"Keep Going" to reach the end of this cut.

Landmark: The Wreck-site

Another Point of Beginning[edit]

You have reached "Another Point of Beginning".

This is where we take account for our journey so far.

You can trace the path you have taken through this Knowledge-Land-Scape by clicking the "trace" bar in the upper left corner of your screen. It will allow you to account for some of the insights that your journey has given you.

The map below shows you the full extent of wayfaring possibilities of the scape.

Cut 3 has guided you along the journey of the community-based dynamics of the BearWatch project.

You have been able to thread your own way alongside me and many of the other agential forces that shaped this project.

In the context of community-based research our movements through the world matter. Are we simply transporting ourselves from one point to another, leaving inanimate traces towards predetermined destinations, or are we finding our way along, in lively response to our own unfolding narratives and that of others around us?

"Keep Going" to explore how the different research output creations have continued their material agencies beyond this cut.

Beyond the Cut[edit]

Over the course of 7 years, the BearWatch project has- among others:

a) optimized SNP and genetic sex profiling of polar bear feces - allowing non-invasive identification and sexing of individual polar bears, b) optimized meta-barcoding assays that allow the identification of vertebrate prey and plant diet identification from polar bear faeces - allowing non-invasive monitoring of diet switching of genetically tagged individual bears, c) determined the relationship between heavy metal contaminants in a polar bears faeces and it’s muscle, liver and fat profile- allowing for noninvasive monitoring of spatial and temporal contaminant loads across the Arctic and , d) optimized the species level detection of micro plastic in polar bear faeces - allowing for the real time monitoring of these contaminants in the arctic ecosystem.

Such non-invasive methods will be most valuable, however, when employed as part of sustainable collaborative efforts between biologists and Inuit communities.

The insights coming from my wayfaring method and prospective aesthetic action within the BearWatch project, have materialized in insights and spaces that may allow for continued work in Gjoa Haven on renewed terms of engagement.

Instead of participation and integration of Inuit Knowledge, follow-up research between BearWatch PI's and Gjoa Haven has now been formulated in terms of co-leadership and is preceded by a "setting of the table", which will include the negotiation of knowledge weaving methods and decision-making protocols under guidance of the ICC EEE protocols, and in according with the principles of Ethical Engagement.

No follow-up project has, so far, materialized with-in Coral Harbour.



Detour to Cut 1: Voices of Thunder

Detour to Cut 2: Aesthetic Action Point of Beginning

Detour to Cut 3: Wayfaring the BearWatch Project